There’s another paper about the Fermi Paradox highlighted on the arXiv blog today. This one describes extensive numerical simulations which purport to show that no more than 1,000 spacefaring civilizations can be exploring the galaxy with non-replicating slower-than-light robotic probes.
Of course, this is highly contingent on a bunch of assumptions about the behavior of these imagined aliens. Enough so that the numbers seem to be pulled out of the air– why would you assume that robotic probes last 50 million years? What makes that a reasonable figure?
It’s clear that the authors have put a lot of work into this, but I have a hard time taking this seriously. It’s just a little too… science-fictional. There are just too many unjustified assumptions going into the whole thing for it to have any real meaning. I suppose it does put limits on the existence of civilizations who think just like physicists on Earth, but it’s not at all clear why we should expect aliens to be that way.